I think you are naive if you think 95% of the programs are totally “clean.” There are more Lane Kiffen types than you may think. What schools should I start with? Penn State, Baylor, Louisville,…
My post was complementing him as he is an off the field leader and respected, but we need to move on and progress to get to the next level on the field.
Martin may be one of the most overrated coaches in Division I football. After 13 seasons, his overall record remains essentially .500. He repeatedly struggles against nonconference competition which raises serious questions about his coaching ceiling.
Despite enjoying more than a decade of stability, he has failed to translate his MAC success into sustained success nationally.
At some point, longevity stops being evidence of success and starts becoming evidence of an athletic department’s willingness to tolerate mediocrity.
You’re 100% correct about the lack of vision, but I think we’re overrating how much it matters in fan support. Chuck could be the same iffy coach with a ho-hum attitude and I don’t think we’d really care if he kept up 2023-esq winning. We’re disturbingly close to a 8-1 record even with a really bad secondary and inconsistent offense, but I think we’d all be more than happy with this season (and Chuck’s job would be secure) if it meant a win over UC and another MACC bid on the horizon.